Transitional Credit — According to the Petitioner, the Petitioner attempted to file TRAN-1 Form on 27 December 2017. However, it could not file the same, as according to the Petitioner, there were problems on the common portal. Held that—the time limit stipulated under Rule 117 of the Rules is not ultra vires of the Act. This Rule is traceable to the power conferred under section 164(2) of the Act. The time limit stipulated in Rule 117 is in consonance with the transitional nature of the enactment, and it is neither arbitrary nor unreasonable. Availment of input tax credit under section 140(1) is a concession attached with conditions of its exercise within the time limit. The IT Grievance Redressal Cell is set up by the GST Council to examine the existence of technical difficulties on the common portal. Sufficient guidance is provided in the definition of technical difficulty in Rule 117(1A). Examining the system log to ascertain the existence of technical difficulties on the common portal for registered persons, is not arbitrary, nor does it lead to a fettering of discretion by the authorities. Those registered persons who could not submit the declaration by the due date because of technical difficulties on the common portal as can be evidenced from the system logs are given an extension on the recommendation of the Council. Where no such evidence is forthcoming, no recommendation is made. In the Petitioner’s case, no such proof emerges and, therefore, no direction as sought for can be issued.

Nelco Limited Vs. The Union of India, The Central Board of Indirect Taxes And Customs, The State of Maharashtra, The Goods And Services Tax Council, The Commissioner of State Tax [2020] 22 TAXLOK.COM 058 (Bombay)