Shanti Prime Publication Pvt. Ltd.
Valuation of Supply — The short point for determination is whether the value of the components manufactured and supplied by the Appellant should include the cost of the tools which are supplied by the customer free of cost and used by the Appellant in the manufacture of the components.
Held that— We set aside the ruling of the AAR and hold that the cost of the tools supplied by the OEM customer on FOC basis to the Appellant is not required to be added to the value of the components supplied by the Appellant. We emphasize that the ruling given by us in this appeal proceeding is based on examination of the contract and purchase orders furnished by the Appellant in the case of their customer M/s. Daimler India Commercial Vehicles Pvt Ltd. This ruling will apply to other contracts entered into by the Appellant only if the terms and conditions contained therein are the same as those contained in the contract placed before us.—Nash Industries (I) Pvt. Ltd., In Re…  10 TAXLOK.COM 006 (AAAR-Karnataka)